Free Independant Advice

Specialist Insolvency Practitioners

Compulsory Liquidation vs Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation

Get in Touch Today to Speak to a Specialist Adviser

Compulsory liquidation is a type of liquidation that occurs when a company is forced to wind up its affairs and finances by its creditors due to insolvency or other reasons.

Creditors’ voluntary liquidation, on the other hand, is initiated by the company’s directors when they believe the business is no longer viable and cannot continue to pay its debts.

A key difference between compulsory and voluntary liquidation is the control of the company.

In compulsory liquidation, the company is no longer under the control of its directors, while in voluntary liquidation, the directors can choose to appoint a liquidator and control the process to some extent.

Directors of a company facing liquidation should be aware of the consequences, including potential investigations by the Official Receiver and Insolvency Service, and the need to pay off creditors.

It is important to carefully consider the type of liquidation and seek professional advice to minimize the impact on the company and its stakeholders.

When it comes to closing a business, liquidation can be a viable option. If you’re exploring this option, it’s crucial to know the differences between types of liquidation.

In this section, we’ll begin by looking at the definition of liquidation in business.

We’ll discuss why it’s important to understand the different types of liquidation available to businesses in financial distress. So, let’s dive in!

Definition of Liquidation in Business

Liquidation in business refers to the process of winding up a company’s affairs and assets, distributing the proceeds among creditors and shareholders, and dissolving the company. It involves terminating all operations and ceasing trading activities permanently. Two types of liquidation exist: compulsory liquidation and voluntary liquidation.

Compulsory liquidation happens when a court issues an order against a company to wind up its affairs due to insolvency. Creditors that the company owes money to usually obtain court orders. This type of liquidation may lead to investigations by the Official Receiver and Insolvency Service, which could result in potential director disqualifications.

In contrast, voluntary liquidations occur when directors decide that their company has come to an end due to various reasons such as retirement or materializing losses. Members’ Voluntary Liquidations (MVLs) are preferred for solvent companies where directors initiate it voluntarily while Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidations (CVLs) are initiated by directors or shareholders who can no longer pay their debts.

The differences between compulsory and voluntary liquidations lie mainly in how they begin, who controls the process (creditors vs directors), and the purpose (either solvency or insolvency). In compulsory liquidations, creditors take control through a receiver appointed by the court while in voluntary situations, the emphasis is on maintaining control for shareholders and sending notices through shareholder resolutions after appointing an independent official receiver.

Liquidations can have consequences for directors’ reputations and their future businesses. Investigations may be commenced by Official Receivers or Insolvency Services looking out for breaches of duties like fraudulent trades and misconducts alongside payment of creditors amidst borderline cases, depending on whether a person benefits from preference rights over others.

Importance of Knowing the Types of Liquidation

Understanding the various types of liquidation in business is of utmost importance for any company director. It can spell the difference between the closure of a struggling company or an organized cessation of operations for a solvent one.

Familiarity with voluntary liquidation, compulsory liquidation, and members’ voluntary liquidation is one of the fundamental things business owners should have.

Thus, they can make informed decisions when faced with financial challenges or insolvency.

When determining the type of liquidation to use, directors must evaluate their company’s financial standing carefully.

With the right approach, they can protect their interests while minimizing the impact on their creditors.

Directors must also be aware of the differences between compulsory and voluntary liquidation.

The former puts control of the company in the hands of a court-appointed official receiver, while the latter allows members to choose a Liquidator as long as they satisfy specific legal criteria.

By understanding these nuances, companies can undergo liquidation with minimal disruption and damage.

Types of Liquidation

When a company is in financial distress, liquidation may become a necessary course of action.

There are two types of liquidation processes: compulsory and voluntary.

In this discussion, we will examine the distinctions between the two methods of liquidation.

We will delve into the details of each process, including who initiates it, how it operates, and what happens to the company’s assets. Join us as we unravel the intricacies of liquidation procedures.

Compulsory Liquidation

Compulsory liquidation is a situation in which a company is forced to sell and distribute all of its assets, properties, and property rights to pay off its debts.

This process can only be initiated by a creditor who serves the company with a statutory demand that is specific to the debt owed.

There are several reasons why the process of liquidation is started, including increased financial loss, cash crisis, or any other major issue that affects the viability of the business.

Once the court receives the petition for winding up the company on grounds of insolvency, an official receiver is appointed to take possession of all assets owned by the debtor.

The liquidator is responsible for realizing these assets or funds and distributing them among the creditors in an order specified by law in strict adherence. Any remaining debt after distribution among creditors becomes discharged.

It is essential that the liquidator investigates company dealings and reports to various government officials, including the Registrar of Companies, Secretary of State, or Insolvency Service, for such matters relevant.

To avoid legal proceedings against directors, early initiation of Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation and consultation from reliable insolvency practitioners should be considered.

In case the company is solvent, a Members’ Voluntary Liquidation procedure can be initiated, where all debts are paid off before shareholders receive their incomes. Within every type of liquidation, the expenses incurred during administration come first ahead of any payment distribution.

A company’s downfall can lead to its compulsory liquidation, crushing the dreams of the CEO and everyone else involved.

How Compulsory Liquidation Occurs

Compulsory Liquidation can be a harsh reality for businesses that are struggling with mounting debts.

Usually, this happens when creditors file a winding-up petition against a company, and the Court determines liquidation to be the most suitable solution available. This process entails transferring power from the hands of company directors and shareholders to an appointed liquidator.

The liquidator then takes charge of the company’s assets and, based on the nature of their claims, decides how to distribute them among creditors.

Once a winding-up petition has been submitted to the court, the creditor needs to convince the judge that their debt is outstanding, and there is no hope of recovery.

They must also establish that liquidation offers better returns to creditors than other alternatives. If the Court accepts these claims, it orders compulsory liquidation.

During the process of compulsory liquidation, the official receiver contacts all parties concerned to inform them about what will happen next.

The liquidator distributes any remaining funds left after secured creditors have claimed their share. Unsecured creditors are usually given reports outlining the company’s affairs before closing down operations. This is what marks the end of a company’s life-cycle.

Directors of companies that undergo compulsory liquidation may suffer significant consequences. They may be required to return assets wrongfully acquired by them or compensate creditors in some situations. It is, therefore, crucial for individuals who wish to avoid these possible legal repercussions to seek professional advice regarding their options, such as Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation. Opting for voluntary liquidation is akin to jumping off a sinking ship before it hits the iceberg.

Voluntary Liquidation

Voluntary liquidation is a process that a company may choose to undertake when it decides to wind up its operations and distribute the proceeds from selling its assets among its creditors.

There are two types of voluntary liquidation, Members’ Voluntary Liquidation (MVL) and Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation (CVL), available to companies depending on their financial status.

If a company is solvent, it may decide to opt for an MVL. In this type of liquidation, the shareholders vote to wind up the company voluntarily, and a liquidator is appointed to manage the payment of liabilities, sale of assets, and distribution of funds among stakeholders.

However, if a company is insolvent, it may choose to initiate a CVL. This type of liquidation involves winding up the company voluntarily after the creditors have decided to do so.

For a CVL to begin, the directors must pass a winding-up resolution.

It is important to note that even though voluntary liquidation may seem like an easier option than compulsory liquidation, directors must still meet various legal criteria to avoid facing potential legal consequences.

In an MVL, the directors must make sure that the creditors receive their payments before initiating voluntary liquidation. In a CVL, they must avoid fraudulent trading.

Voluntary liquidation can be an effective way for companies to wind up their operations while following legal requirements.

However, it is crucial to understand the key differences between MVL and CVL and navigate the process with the help of experts in the field.

Members’ Voluntary Liquidation

When a company has satisfied all of its liabilities and feels that it is time to distribute its remaining assets, it may choose to undergo a Members’ Voluntary Liquidation (MVL) process.

During this process, a liquidator is appointed to take control of the company and sell its assets, paying off creditors in full and realising any remaining funds.

These funds are then distributed among shareholders, and a statement of solvency is issued confirming that the directors have carried out their statutory duties.

It is important to note that if the company is not solvent at the time it decides to liquidate, MVL may not be appropriate, and compulsory liquidation proceedings enforced by creditors may take place.

However, MVL can have benefits, such as a more straightforward process than compulsory liquidation and reducing the risk of legal challenges from creditors.

It can also provide corporate or personal tax savings compared to standard income and capital gains taxes for shareholders.

Stakeholders in a company should perform due diligence to determine whether MVL is an appropriate course of action.

Seeking expert advice can be crucial in complex or challenging situations where the distribution of assets between creditors and shareholders needs to be carefully considered.

Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation

In Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation, shareholders have the power to appoint an insolvency practitioner as a liquidator instead of relying on court officials.

This can be a beneficial option for businesses facing financial difficulties and looking to take a proactive approach to addressing these issues. The main responsibility of the liquidator is to secure any remaining assets and distribute them fairly among all stakeholders involved in the company.

Creditor claims are resolved based on priority order, and any outstanding debts are paid off before any remaining funds are distributed to shareholders. Once everything has been settled, the company is dissolved and removed from the Companies House registry.

One of the unique aspects of Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation is that it is typically less expensive than Compulsory Liquidation.

This is because there are no legal proceedings or petition fees involved in court applications. Directors are also permitted to gather necessary information for the liquidator and manage communication with employees as they begin the voluntary winding-up procedure.

Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation can be an effective way for insolvent businesses to handle financial issues in a fair and orderly manner.

This method is often utilized when companies need to restructure or downsize in response to decreased profitability. Choosing whether to pursue compulsory or voluntary liquidation can be a difficult decision, but understanding the differences between the two options is critical in making an informed choice.

Differences between Compulsory and Voluntary Liquidation

When it comes to liquidation, there are two paths a company can take – compulsory or voluntary.

The key differences between the two should be examined closely. Depending on which route is taken, the control of the company and the appointment of a liquidator can vary.

This insight provides valuable information about each approach.

Control of the Company

Understanding the control of a company during liquidation is crucial.

In compulsory liquidation, the directors relinquish control, and it is taken over by the official receiver. On the other hand, in voluntary liquidation, the directors continue to have control until the appointment of a licensed insolvency practitioner (IP) as a liquidator.

In mandatory liquidation, the official receiver assumes control and manages the company’s affairs.

They liquidate the assets and distribute the proceeds among creditors. However, in voluntary liquidation, directors retain control until the IP’s appointment as the liquidator.

It’s important to note that in a voluntary liquidation if there are any suspicions of misconduct or fraudulent activities by company directors or other stakeholders, the IP may take control before the completion of the winding-up process.

This could lead to investigations by regulatory bodies, such as The Insolvency Service, or even criminal trials in severe cases.

Appointment of a Liquidator

The appointment of a liquidator is a crucial step in any business liquidation process. In the case of compulsory liquidation, an official receiver appointed by the court serves as the first liquidator.

On the other hand, in voluntary liquidation, members or creditors can nominate a specific individual to act as the liquidator.

It is important that the appointed liquidator holds the necessary qualifications and license to carry out their duties effectively.

Their primary responsibilities include collecting and selling the business’s assets and distributing the proceeds to the creditors involved. It is best to agree on the appointment before the formal liquidation proceedings begin.

In compulsory liquidation, the directors may have limited control over who gets appointed as the liquidator unlike in voluntary liquidation.

Therefore, it is advisable for them to seek professional guidance to minimize negative consequences that may arise.

Failing to appoint a skilled and experienced liquidator can result in significant delays in winding up operations and can lead to a rise in costs or legal action by stakeholders.

Therefore, it is critical for companies undergoing any type of liquidation to hire a professional liquidator as quickly as possible.

Choosing Between Compulsory and Voluntary Liquidation

Liquidation of a company can be a daunting and overwhelming task, especially if you are unsure about which route to take. In this section, we will make choosing between compulsory and voluntary liquidation easier for you.

We will explore initiating Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation and Members’ Voluntary Liquidation for Solvent Companies, and help you make the right decision for your business.

Initiating Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation

To initiate a Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation, the directors must obtain agreement from at least 75% of the company’s creditors to proceed with winding up.

The liquidator will then be appointed by the creditors. During this process, all business activities will cease, and the directors will work closely with the appointed liquidator to ensure that all outstanding debts are paid in full.

It is important to note that initiating Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation can have significant consequences for both directors and their companies.

The Insolvency Service may conduct investigations into the financial affairs of directors, which could lead to disqualification from acting as a director in future.

Additionally, all creditor claims must be satisfied before any distribution can be made to shareholders.

In the case of solvent companies, Members’ Voluntary Liquidation is a way of closing down but ensuring that all creditors are paid before distributing any remaining funds to shareholders.

Members’ Voluntary Liquidation for Solvent Companies

Members’ Voluntary Liquidation is a viable option for solvent companies that want to cease their operations and distribute their assets among shareholders.

This type of liquidation is ideal for businesses that have surplus resources, seek an alternative return on investment, or no longer wish to engage in trading activities.

In Members’ Voluntary Liquidation, the directors maintain control over the process and can appoint a licensed insolvency practitioner to become the liquidator.

To kickstart this process, the directors must draft a resolution outlining their intentions and submit it to Companies House within 15 days. They must also provide a declaration of solvency confirming that the company can repay all its debts with interest within 12 months of winding up.

Once the resolution and declaration are published, creditors and members can object to the proposal before it is approved via a shareholders’ meeting.

Unlike Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation, Members’ Voluntary Liquidation distributes assets among shareholders after repaying all debts with interest, providing capital gains tax benefits.

It is important to note that if the company cannot fulfil its obligations during liquidation, it may result in compulsory liquidation or investigations by the Insolvency Service.

As a director, it is crucial to be cautious of investigations and creditor payments to avoid any damage to your reputation.

Consequences of Liquidation for Directors and their Companies

With the potentially devastating consequences of liquidation looming over directors and their companies, it is crucial to understand the events that occur in the event of mandatory liquidation or voluntary liquidation by creditors.

In this section, we will delve deeper into two key factors of which directors must be knowledgeable: probes conducted by the Official Receiver and the Insolvency Service, and the payment of creditors.

Let’s examine the specifics of these processes and the ways in which they could potentially affect the future of the company.

Investigations by the Official Receiver and the Insolvency Service

The Official Receiver and the Insolvency Service are responsible for conducting investigations into companies that have gone into liquidation in the UK.

These investigations have the goal of determining whether the directors engaged in any unauthorized, illegal, or dishonest behavior that contributed to the insolvency of the company.

The Insolvency Service, a government agency that administers and regulates insolvency procedures, oversees these investigations.

During the investigation process, the Official Receiver will carefully examine financial documents like bank statements, invoices, and contracts related to the company.

In addition, the Official Receiver may interview directors, shareholders, and other individuals who may possess pertinent information that helps to determine the root cause of the company’s insolvency, and if any malfeasance has occurred.

The Insolvency Service has extensive powers under Section 447 of the Companies Act 1985 and can launch investigations when wrongdoing on the part of company directors is suspected.

If findings of wrongdoing come to light during the inquiry, legal action can be taken against those discovered to be culpable of misconduct; such measures may include disqualification as a director or prosecution for criminal offences.

To preclude investigations by the Official Receiver or actions taken against them by the Insolvency Service following liquidation, company directors must act transparently and with honesty in all dealings with creditors prior to liquidation.

They must comply with accounting and reporting standards while fully cooperating with any inquiries conducted by officials.

Payment of Creditors

When a business enters into liquidation, it becomes imperative to prioritise the payment of creditors’ outstanding debts. In the case of compulsory liquidation, an appointed liquidator takes control of the company’s assets and sells them off to repay creditors.

The repayment follows the priority order set by law. On the contrary, during voluntary liquidation, the directors must ensure that creditors are paid off before distributing any remaining assets to shareholders.

During the liquidation process, creditors are notified and requested to submit their claims for payment.

The liquidator then reviews these claims and pays from the available funds, keeping in mind the legal priorities.

In instances where the funds are insufficient to pay off all the creditors, they are paid a proportion according to their debt size.

Directors of the company in liquidation should be aware that they might be held liable for any incurred debt if they fail to cooperate fully with the appointed liquidator during the liquidation process. Cooperation includes providing precise and complete company records.

BHS is an example of a company that underwent administration in 2016 with a debt of £1.3 billion, with the pension fund receiving £571 million.

However, the administrators were unable to find a buyer for the company as a going concern. The company was thus sold piecemeal over many years, with the proceeds being used to pay off creditors. The former owner was subjected to an investigation over his handling of the business before its collapse.

Conclusion and Recommended Actions

After conducting a thorough analysis of compulsory liquidation and creditors’ voluntary liquidation, it is evident that both options come with pros and cons.

However, depending on the company’s financial health and current circumstances, one option may be more suitable than the other. It is recommended that company directors seek professional advice before making any decision.

In compulsory liquidation, the company is forced to shut down by creditors. The appointed liquidator holds extensive power to investigate and pursue actions against the company directors if there is any suspicion of misconduct.

On the other hand, creditors’ voluntary liquidation is initiated by the company director and allows them to retain some control over the process and potentially initiate a company rescue, subject to the approval of creditors. However, both options seek to settle outstanding debts and distribute remaining assets among creditors.

Five Facts About Compulsory Liquidation vs Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation:

  • ✅ Compulsory liquidation occurs when a company is forced to liquidate by its creditors because it cannot afford to pay its bills and settle its debts, while voluntary liquidation is initiated by the company’s directors. (Sources: Clarke Bell, AABRS, Real Business Rescue, Company Rescue)
  • ✅ The process of compulsory liquidation begins with a winding-up petition issued by the creditors to the court, while voluntary liquidation involves passing a resolution to wind up the company, appointing a liquidator, and notifying Companies House. (Sources: Clarke Bell, AABRS, Real Business Rescue, Company Rescue)
  • ✅ Members’ voluntary liquidation (MVL) is for solvent companies that can pay their debts in full, while creditors’ voluntary liquidation (CVL) is for insolvent companies that cannot pay their debts in full and need to liquidate their affairs. (Sources: Clarke Bell, AABRS, Real Business Rescue)
  • ✅ In a compulsory liquidation, complete control of the company is handed over to the official receiver, while the company’s directors can choose the liquidator, who must be a licensed insolvency practitioner, in a creditors’ voluntary liquidation. (Sources: AABRS, Real Business Rescue)
  • ✅ The difference between compulsory and voluntary liquidation affects the implications for the directors and the ability to prepare and take actions to reduce creditors’ losses or capitalize on stock and assets for a better return. It is important for directors to understand the differences before deciding on the best route forward. (Sources: Clarke Bell, AABRS, Real Business Rescue, Company Rescue)

FAQs about Compulsory Liquidation Vs Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation

What is the difference between compulsory liquidation and creditors’ voluntary liquidation?

Liquidation is the formal insolvency process where a company winds up its affairs and finances. There are two types of liquidation: compulsory and voluntary. Compulsory liquidation occurs when a company is forced to liquidate by its creditors because it cannot afford to pay its bills and settle its debts.

Creditors must issue a winding-up petition to the court to begin the process of compulsory liquidation. If the creditors are successful, the company will be forced into liquidation and its assets will be sold to repay outstanding debts.

On the other hand, voluntary liquidation occurs when the company’s directors decide to liquidate the company. The process of voluntary liquidation involves passing a resolution to wind up the company, appointing a liquidator, and notifying Companies House.

The differences between compulsory and voluntary liquidation include the way they are initiated and the implications for the company and its directors. In a compulsory liquidation, the company is forced to liquidate by its creditors and the complete control of the company is handed over to the liquidator.

In a voluntary liquidation, the company’s directors choose to liquidate the company and can choose their liquidator. Voluntary liquidation can be either members’ voluntary liquidation (MVL) or creditors’ voluntary liquidation (CVL), depending on the company’s financial situation. MVL is for solvent companies that can pay their debts in full, while CVL is for insolvent companies that cannot pay their debts in full.

What is the best route for a company that is insolvent?

If a company cannot pay all its debts, the best route is to go for a creditors’ voluntary liquidation (CVL). This type of liquidation allows the directors to choose the liquidator, prepare better for the process, and take actions to reduce the creditors’ losses or capitalize on the company’s stock and assets for better returns.

Initiating the liquidation process also allows the director to prepare for it and take actions to reduce creditors’ losses or capitalize on stock and assets for a better return for the company.

What happens to a company in voluntary liquidation?

When a company is in voluntary liquidation, the directors make a resolution to wind up the company, appoint a liquidator, and notify Companies House.

The company is dissolved, struck off the Companies House register by the end of the process, and any remaining funds after liquidation go to the creditors.

What is the difference between Members’ Voluntary Liquidation and Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation?

Members’ Voluntary Liquidation (MVL) is for solvent companies that can pay their debts in full, while Creditors’ Voluntary Liquidation (CVL) is for insolvent companies that cannot pay their debts in full.

The main difference is that in MVL, the company owners are looking to close their business and extract profits, while in CVL, the company directors are forced to wind up the company due to their insolvency and cannot pay their creditors.

What is the role of licensed insolvency practitioners in the liquidation process?

Licensed insolvency practitioners are appointed in both compulsory and voluntary liquidations to handle the company’s liquidation process.

They take control of the company’s liquidation, sell its assets, and pay the creditors as much as possible. They also investigate the directors’ conduct and report any signs of wrongful or fraudulent trading to the Insolvency Service.

How can Real Business Rescue help and provide advice during the liquidation process?

Real Business Rescue is available to provide free and confidential advice for those going through the liquidation process.

They can help company directors understand the differences between compulsory and voluntary liquidation, the implications for themselves and their company, and suggest the best route forward.

Their professionals provide an initial consultation and help throughout the liquidation process. You can call them at 0800 644 6080 for help and advice.

Get In Touch With Our Team

We Aim To Reply To All Enquiries With-in 24-Hours